HOME RATES ABOUT SERVICES VIDEO BLOG CONTACT ME TEAM
AGENT LICENSE ID
M21002209
BROKERAGE LICENSE ID
10500
Mike Cara Mortgage Broker

Mike Cara

Mortgage Broker


Phone:
Address:
398 McDonnel St., Unit 4, Peterborough , Ontario, K9H 2X4

BROWSE

PARTNERS

COMPLETE

THE SURVEY

REFER

A FRIEND

Mortgage Refinancing in Peterborough – How to Save Thousands

9/25/2025

Refinancing your mortgage is more than just swapping lenders—it can be a powerful tool to reduce your monthly payments, tap into equity, or cut years off your loan. But it’s not right for everyone. In Peterborough, with its unique real estate market and interest-rate landscape, refinancing smartly can save you real money.

What Is Mortgage Refinancing?

Mortgage refinancing means replacing your current mortgage with a new one—either with your existing lender or a new one. The new mortgage may have:

  • A lower interest rate
  • A different term length (shorter or longer amortization)
  • Cash‐out options (use home equity to get money)
  • Better conditions (e.g. fixed vs variable rate, better prepayment options)

In Ontario, you can usually refinance up to 80% of your home’s appraised value, less what you currently owe.

Why Now Might Be a Good Time in Peterborough

Here are some reasons why homeowners in Peterborough should pay close attention:

  • Current mortgage rates locally: According to Nesto.ca, the average 4-year fixed-insurable mortgage rate in Peterborough is approximately 5.59%, and the 7-year rate is around 6.29%. (nesto.ca) These are high enough that if you have an older mortgage with worse terms, you may be able to save.
  • Potential to lower monthly payments: With even a drop of 1% or more in your rate, the interest portion of your payments could decrease significantly over the life of the mortgage.
  • Accumulated equity: Over time, as home values in Peterborough rise (or at least stay steady) and you pay down principal, you build more equity. If you have substantial equity (e.g., 20% or more of the home's value), you have negotiating power.
  • Higher debt costs elsewhere: If you're paying high interest for credit cards, lines of credit, or other debts, refinancing could let you consolidate at a lower mortgage rate.
  • Flexible housing market: If you plan to stay in your home for several more years, savings from refinancing could outweigh the upfront costs. If moving soon, less so.

Costs & Pitfalls to Watch Out For

Refinancing isn’t free. Some of the costs can add up, and sometimes hidden ones make the math less favourable than it seems.

Cost / Factor

Typical Amount in Ontario / Peterborough Area

What To Watch Out For

Prepayment penalty / “breaking your mortgage”

For fixed mortgages: often 3 months’ interest or the interest rate differential (IRD)—whichever is higher. (NerdWallet)

If much time remains in your current term, these penalties can be very steep. Be sure you can cover them or that the long-term savings make up for them.

Legal fees

~$750-$1,500 or more. (WOWA)

The price depends on the complexity, whether you change lenders, title issues, and whether you hire a local lawyer or use a panel.

Home appraisal fee

~$300-$600. (WOWA)

If your home value has changed significantly, the appraisal could go your way (if it's up), but sometimes costs and wait times can be annoying.

Mortgage discharge/registration fees

Discharge fee: $200-$400; registration: $70-$100. (WOWA)

If you're staying with the same lender and not moving from a collateral-secured loan, some fees may be lower or waived.

Title insurance and other legal costs

Could add a few hundred more. 

Ensure you understand what's included in legal fees; sometimes title insurance is required.

Interest rate & amortization effects

If you extend the amortization period, you may pay more interest over the long term, even if your monthly payment is lower.

Don’t just focus on monthly savings—look at the total cost over the life of the mortgage.

Estimating How Much You Can Save – Examples

Let’s run through a couple of example scenarios to show what savings might look like in Peterborough.

Example 1: Lowering the interest rate, staying on a similar term

  • Current mortgage: $350,000 balance, 20 years left, interest rate 6.50%, fixed.
  • Refinance option: New rate 5.25%, similar 20-year amortization.
  • Penalty: Assume 3 months’ interest (on the current mortgage), plus legal/appraisal, etc.

Rough calculation:

  • Current payment (assuming monthly): ~$2,690
  • New payment (5.25%): ~$2,399
  • Monthly savings: ~$291
  • Over 20 years, that’s $291 × 240 months = $69,840 in payments avoided (excluding penalties and fees).

Subtract costs: say penalty = $4,000, appraisal + legal + other fees = $2,500. So, net savings over the full term ≈ are approximately $63,000.

Break-even: about 6–8 months (divide total costs by monthly savings).

Example 2: Accessing equity & debt consolidation

  • You owe $250,000, with a home appraised at $400,000, resulting in 50% equity.
  • You want to pull out $50,000 to consolidate credit card debt (with an interest rate of ~20%), plus make some renovations.

If you refinance for $300,000 at 5.25% over 25 years:

  • You increase your mortgage balance by $50,000, but the monthly interest is far lower than what credit cards cost.
  • Even if the monthly mortgage payment goes up somewhat, you replace multiple high-interest debt payments.

Depending on your debt load, this could save you thousands per year in interest. Renovations can increase a home's value, further enhancing its equity.

Peterborough-Specific Numbers & Rates

Here are a few rates and data points specific to Peterborough to help local homeowners decide:

  • Average 4-year fixed insurable rate: ~ 5.59%. (nesto.ca)
  • Average 7-year fixed insurable rate: ~ 6.29%. (nesto.ca)
  • Typical penalty/discharge fees in Ontario: $200-$400 for discharge, registration ~$70-$100. (WOWA)

Given those, homeowners with older mortgages locked in at 6.5% or higher, especially those with fixed-rate mortgages, stand to gain from refinancing if they can find sub-5.5% fixed or variable options, subject to lender qualification.

Key Steps & Tips to Ensure You Actually Save

  1. Gather your current mortgage details.
    • Balance remaining, rate, term, amortization, whether fixed or variable, and when you can refinance without a massive penalty.
    • What is the prepayment penalty if you break the mortgage early? (Ask your lender)
  2. Shop around
    • Talk to multiple lenders (banks, credit unions) and brokers in Peterborough.
    • Obtain quotes that include all applicable fees (legal, appraisal, and discharge). Sometimes lenders offer to cover some of these.
  3. Compute break-even time
    • Calculate how long it will take for your savings to outweigh all refinancing costs. If you plan to stay in your home past that, it's more likely worthwhile.
  4. Check amortization
    • If the refinance means extending the amortization (e.g., from 20 to 25 or 30 years), be aware that you may pay more overall in interest, even if the monthly payments decrease. If possible, consider keeping or shortening the amortization period.
  5. Consider fixed vs variable rate.
    • Fixed gives peace of mind on the rate. A variable can be cheaper initially, but it has a risk. Depending on your tolerance for interest rate volatility, you may prefer one or the other.
  6. Don’t ignore “soft costs”
    • Time spent, paperwork, possibly having to change insurance, title, etc.
    • Additionally, a good credit score and income verification—good financial health helps you secure better rates.
  7. Use a mortgage broker.
    • Local brokers in Peterborough often know lenders who are competitive in the area and might negotiate fees or help you find promotions.

When Refinancing May Not Be Worth It

  • If the prepayment penalty or break-cost is very high (e.g. you’re early in a long-fixed term).
  • If you're planning to sell or move within a short period (maybe 1-2 years), your savings may not cover the upfront costs.
  • If your credit score or debt load has worsened since you obtained your original mortgage, you may not qualify for the better rates.
  • If the only way to reduce payments is to extend amortization significantly (thus increasing total interest paid).

Final Thoughts

Refinancing in Peterborough can save you thousands—sometimes tens of thousands—if you:

  • Lock in a materially lower interest rate than your current rate
  • Manage and minimize fees and penalties
  • Don’t lengthen your time under enormous interest costs unless necessary

It pays to do the math. Local rate drops of 1-1.5% are substantial in the mortgage world. Even a few months fewer in the mortgage term, or switching from fixed high rates to lower fixed or variable rates, can make a meaningful difference.

MY LENDERS

Scotia Bank TD Bank First National EQ Bank MCAP Merix
Home Trust CMLS Manulife RFA B2B Bank Community Trust
Lifecycle Mortgage ICICI Bank Radius Financial HomeEquity Bank CMI Bridgewater
Sequence Capital Wealth One Fisgard Capital Bloom Financial NationalBank